20 April, 2020

Quora Answer: Which is the Best Insurance Company in Singapore?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “Which is the best insurance company in Singapore: AIA, Prudential or GE Life?”

There is no best insurer.  There is only the insurer that is best for what you need.  And then, there is the quality of the financial services consultant.

Great Eastern Life is the largest insurer in Singapore.  It is also the oldest, founded in 1908 by Alfred Hewton Fair.  With total assets above S$100 billion and more than 16 million policyholders, it is the dominant force by sheer mass.  It generated S$11.9 billion in gross premiums in 2023 — down 15.9 per cent from S$14.1 billion in 2022, but still nearly double its nearest competitor.

Prudential is second, with S$7.1 billion in gross premiums in 2023 — a 21.7 per cent fall from S$9.0 billion in 2022.  AIA Singapore ranks third, with S$6.6 billion — a decline of just 0.6 per cent.  In a year when the entire market fell 9 per cent on gross premiums, AIA held its ground.  That is the first useful data point.  The industry-wide decline is not a crisis.  It reflects the unwinding of single-premium investment flows that inflated 2022 figures.  The underlying life insurance market in Singapore is structurally sound.  What has changed is how these three players are positioned.

Great Eastern: The Incumbent and the Saga

Great Eastern is a Singapore institution.  It insures some 5 million people through government health schemes alone.  It contributes an average of S$700 million a year in net profit to its parent, OCBC Bank — about 15 per cent of OCBC’s annual earnings.  That relationship has become complicated.  OCBC holds 94 per cent of Great Eastern.  In 2025, it offered S$30.15 per share — S$900 million for the remaining 6.28 per cent — to delist the insurer from SGX.  Sixty-three and a half per cent of minority shareholders voted in favour.  The threshold for delisting was not met.  The bid lapsed.  Shares, suspended since July 2024, resumed trading.  OCBC now must issue new shares to meet exchange listing requirements, which will dilute its stake to about 88 per cent.  The whole episode told the market something useful.  Minority shareholders, offered a 17.8 per cent premium over the previous bid, still refused.  They think Great Eastern is worth more than OCBC does.  The insurer OCBC wanted off the exchange is the one policyholders have trusted for 117 years.

Great Eastern’s market position is built on distribution breadth and pricing competitiveness for mass-market products.  Its Shield plans — MediShield Life-integrated hospitalisation coverage — have historically offered more forgiving underwriting for clients with pre-existing conditions.  That changed after the insurer absorbed heavy claims losses.  Underwriting has tightened.  The competitive advantage of loading decisions has narrowed.  What remains is brand legacy and the sheer depth of its distribution network.  For the HNW segment, Great Eastern is not the natural choice.  It is a volume player.  Volume players are not engineered for complexity.

Prudential: The Retreat

Prudential is a FTSE 100 insurer headquartered in London.  Its Asia operation, Prudential Asia, spun off as a separately listed entity on the Hong Kong and London stock exchanges in 2021, under the ticker PRU.  For Singapore clients, the entity is Prudential Assurance Company Singapore (Pte) Ltd.  The 21.7 per cent fall in gross premiums from 2022 to 2023 is the most severe decline among the three.  It is not purely a Singapore story — the whole region saw premium compression — but Prudential’s position in Singapore has softened.

Prudential’s investment-linked plans use external fund managers — Fidelity, Eastspring, and others — rather than captive fund management.  Every layer of external management adds a cost.  Fund management charges sit on top of policy fees, mortality charges, and administration costs.  The total expense ratio on a Prudential ILP sub-fund can be materially higher than on an equivalent AIA platform fund, depending on the fund selected.  The difference compounds over decades.  On a 25-year plan, the difference in net returns is not theoretical.  It is retirement capital.  Prudential’s strengths are in term insurance and its PRULink ILP range, which offers broad fund selection.  Its critical illness products have been competitive.  The distribution force is experienced and large.  None of that changes the structural cost disadvantage on the investment-linked side.

AIA: The Premium Position

AIA Singapore is the Singapore arm of AIA Group, the largest pan-Asian independent insurance group by market capitalisation.  AIA Group posted record results in 2024.  AIA Singapore’s Annualised New Premium grew 52 per cent to USD897 million.  Its Value of New Business grew 15 per cent, with double-digit growth in both agency and partnership distribution.  The organisation has held the Number 1 position for Million-Dollar Round Table qualifying members in Singapore for the tenth consecutive time.  The MDRT is the global benchmark for top-producing life insurance professionals.  One-tenth of AIA is the result of a deliberate strategy to recruit and retain the upper decile of the financial services consultant market.

AIA’s pricing is higher.  That is not a secret.  It is the point.  AIA targets affluent and HNW clients.  Its product suite reflects that positioning.  The AIA Wealth Centre and AIA International Wealth platform are engineered for clients who require cross-border structuring, estate planning integration, and access to institutional-quality fund managers.  The AIA Platinum Wealth Venture, launched in 2024, gives clients access to global fund managers through the AIA Regional Funds Platform — a structure that was not available on competitors’ platforms at the same price point.  The ILP cost advantage is structural.  Where AIA manages funds internally or through the AIA Regional Funds Platform, the management charge flows to the group rather than to an external fund house.  That changes the alignment of incentives.  The insurer, the fund manager, and the policyholder are on the same side of the ledger.  With external fund managers, the insurer collects the spread; the fund house collects the management fee; the policyholder collects whatever is left.  This is not an argument that AIA is universally superior.  It is an argument that AIA is superior for the client profile it targets.

The Wrong Assumption

The question assumes that the insurer is the variable.  It is not.  The financial services consultant is the variable.  The Monetary Authority of Singapore regulates Singapore’s insurance industry.  Every licensed insurer operates under MAS’s Balanced Scorecard framework, which links compensation to customer outcomes, compliance records, and persistency.  The framework has teeth.  The era of agents churning policies for trail commissions and vanishing before the first claim is structurally harder than it was.  What the framework cannot mandate is judgment.  It cannot compel an agent to suggest that a client nominates a beneficiary.  It cannot force a financial services consultant to review a portfolio after market dislocation.  It cannot require proactive contact when a client’s health changes and a policy lapse would be catastrophic.  Those things require a professional who treats the relationship as ongoing, not transactional.

The worst financial planning outcome in Singapore is not a bad insurer.  It is a good insurer and a mediocre agent.  A client holding a Prudential policy with a financial services consultant who calls quarterly, reviews annually, and understands the client’s estate structure will be better served than the same client holding an AIA policy with an agent who sold the product and moved on.  That said, the pool of top-tier financial services consultants in Singapore skews toward AIA for the HNW segment.

A Framework for the Decision

No single insurer dominates every category.  If the client is a mass-market policyholder buying hospitalisation coverage, term life, or basic whole life, Great Eastern’s breadth of distribution and historical competitive pricing makes it a reasonable default — with the caveat that its underwriting has tightened since the Shield plan losses.  If the client needs a broad universe of ILP sub-funds and is working with a knowledgeable financial services consultant who can navigate the external fund manager cost structure, Prudential’s PRULink range is legitimate.  Most clients do not have one.

If the client is HNW or approaching that threshold — if the mandate involves estate planning, trust structuring, wealth transfer across jurisdictions, or access to institutional fund quality — AIA’s product architecture is the most suitable.  The cost premium is real.  It is also justified by the product capability and the quality of the professional distribution network that serves that segment.  The question is never which insurer.  The question is which financial services consultant, working in which insurer’s ecosystem, can serve your needs over the next 20 to 30 years.  Find that person.  The insurer follows.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.