17 April, 2020

Quora Answer: Is Singapore a First World Country?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “Is Singapore a first-world country?”

The term “Third World” was coined in 1952 by Alfred Adolphe Sauvy, a French demographer, in a magazine article.  He borrowed from the French Revolution’s concept of the tiers état — the Third Estate, the commoners who existed beneath the clergy and the nobility, but whose labour kept the entire system running.  Sauvy was describing countries that sat outside the two great power blocs of the Cold War: not aligned with the United States, not aligned with the Soviet Union, ignored by both, and exploited by both.

“First World” meant the Western capitalist bloc — the United States and its allies.  “Second World” meant the Soviet Union, the Warsaw Pact, and the Communist bloc.  “Third World” meant everyone else: the non-aligned, the poor, the colonial remnants, the nations that the superpowers used as chess pieces and occasionally as proxy battlefields.  These were political categories, not economic ones.  “First World” did not mean “rich.”  It meant “on Washington’s side.”

Singapore, officially, was Third World.  It joined the Non-Aligned Movement in 1970 and remains a member.  ASEAN, as a bloc, deliberately sought neutrality in the superpower conflict.  If you want to be technically precise about the original Cold War taxonomy, Singapore was Third World on paper.  In practice, this was always fiction.  Singapore’s defence posture, its trade relationships, its legal system, and its voting record at the United Nations told a different story.  The Lee Kuan Yew administration understood, better than almost any other government of its era, which side of the Cold War produced prosperity.  The Non-Aligned Movement was a diplomatic convenience.  The economics were never ambiguous.

The Meaning Changed; Singapore Changed Faster

After the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, the Cold War taxonomy became obsolete.  Nobody was “Second World” anymore.  The terminology shifted.  “First World” came to mean developed, democratic, capitalist, and stable.  “Third World” became a euphemism for poor, corrupt, and badly governed — a usage that Sauvy, who intended a structural critique of global power, would have found both ironic and depressing.

Singapore, by any measure that matters, is First World under either definition.  Singapore’s GDP per capita in 2024 stands at US$133,740, ranking it fourth in the world according to IMF data cited by Forbes — behind Luxembourg, Macau, and Ireland, and ahead of the United States, which comes in ninth at US$85,370.  A country once dismissed as a “Third World” port town in 1965 now has a higher income per head than the world’s self-appointed exemplar of First World prosperity.

The 2025 UNDP Human Development Report ranks Singapore 13th globally, with an HDI score of 0.946.  Life expectancy at birth is 83.7 years.  Expected years of schooling are 16.7.  GNI per capita in purchasing power parity terms is US$111,239.  These are not the numbers of a developing nation.  These are the numbers of a country that has, in sixty years, executed one of the most remarkable development trajectories in recorded economic history.  Transparency International’s 2024 Corruption Perceptions Index ranks Singapore third least corrupt in the world and first in Asia-Pacific.  Its public institutions function.  Its civil service delivers.  Its courts are independent enough to terrify people who deserve to be terrified.

OECD Objection

Some commentators raise the fact that Singapore is not a member of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.  This is accurate and irrelevant.  The OECD has thirty-eight members.  Every one of them is a developed nation.  But membership is not a prerequisite for being developed — it is a club with a history, founded in 1961 by Western European nations and North America, expanded over time, and still shaped by the geopolitics of its founding era.  Singapore qualifies by every substantive OECD standard.  It simply does not want to join.  The logic of using OECD membership as the test for “First World” status is the logic of declaring that a man is not wealthy because he does not belong to your specific golf club.  The golf club was not designed with him in mind.  That tells you something about the golf club, not about the man.

Singapore is not merely a First World country.  By the metrics that the term was eventually retrofitted to describe — per capita income, human development, institutional quality, public safety, infrastructure, and economic competitiveness — Singapore outperforms most of the nations that consider themselves the original First World.  It is wealthier than France, Germany, and Japan.  It lives longer than the United States.  Its students outperform every OECD country in mathematics and science in the PISA rankings.  Its corruption score beats the United Kingdom.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code


No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.