18 April, 2020

Quora Answer: Are Singaporeans Proud of Their Policies against Illegal Immigration?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “Are Singaporeans proud of their policies against illegal immigration, such as caning illegal immigrants, jail, and requiring landlords to check the immigration status of renters, after seeing the crisis playing out in the US?”

We cannot compare ourselves to the United States, a country of vastly different proportions, politics, and internal dynamics.  Singapore has 500 to 600 overstayers outstanding at any given time — less than 0.001 per cent of annual visitor arrivals, per a parliamentary reply by then-Home Affairs Minister Kasiviswanathan Shanmugam in November 2024.  That figure is not the product of luck.  It is the product of consequences.  Singapore ranked first globally in Gallup’s 2024 Global Safety Report — its 12th top ranking since the survey began in 2006.  98 per cent of residents said they feel safe walking alone after dark.  This is not an accident.  This is architecture.

What the Law Says

Under the Immigration Act, illegal entry or departure carries a mandatory minimum of three strokes of the cane and up to 6 months’ jail.  Overstaying beyond 90 days earns the same — 3 strokes, 6 months, then deportation.  Harbouring an immigration offender may lead to a jail term of between 6 months and 2 years, plus a fine of up to S$6,000.  Employing one carries the same exposure.  Landlords who fail to verify a tenant’s immigration status face criminal liability.  Ignorance is not an excuse.

The cane is not symbolic.  In August 2024, a 43-year-old Chinese national who had overstayed since October 2023 received six weeks’ jail and three strokes.  His harbourer was fined S$3,000.  A second case in the same period: two years of illegal work at a food stall, 14 weeks’ jail, caning; the employer was warned, and the harbourer fined S$3,500.

Overstayer arrests rose 52 per cent from 357 in 2022 to 542 in 2023.  Those figures are still below pre-pandemic levels of 940 in 2018.  Arrests for harbouring and employing immigration offenders rose 31.6 per cent in the first nine months of 2024 — 304 arrests versus 231 in the same period of 2023.  The ICA runs sixty enforcement operations a month.  The lesson is not that enforcement stops at the border.  It follows the offender inland, into the food stall and the spare bedroom.

Singapore is Not in the Refugee Business

Singapore does not sign the 1951 Refugee Convention.  It does not run an asylum procedure.  It has no intention of starting one.  When pressed in 2015, the government’s position was that a small country with limited land cannot accept people seeking asylum.  This position has historical roots.  After the fall of Saigon in April 1975, refugee vessels began arriving.  The government launched Operation Thunderstorm — the Navy directed ships to anchorages, repaired them, supplied food and water, and made clear that nobody was staying.  Singapore housed 2,000 refugees temporarily on St. John’s Island.  It set a camp capacity of 1,000 people, a 90-day maximum stay, and a requirement that the rescuing ship’s flag country guarantee resettlement before anyone set foot on land.

The last ninety-nine boat people left from Changi Airport on 29 June 1996.  Then-Home Affairs Minister Wong Kan Seng said Singapore had “learnt our lesson” and would not accept refugees even on third-country resettlement guarantees.  That is not cruelty.  That is a city-state of six million people, 728 square kilometres, and a calibrated ethnic and religious balance, making a rational decision about its own survival.  We make no apologies for that.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.