16 April, 2020

Quora Answer: What Could Donald John Trump Offer Democrats to Entice Them to Give US$5 Billion for a Border Wall?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “What could Donald John Trump offer the Democrats that would entice them to give him US$5 billion for a border wall?  Why will Mexico not just pay for it, so we can just open our government?”

Why will Mexico not just pay for it?  Because Mexico is a sovereign nation of 130 million people, not a vassal state that exists to fund the vanity projects of its northern neighbour’s more excitable administrations.  The question assumes Mexico owes the United States something.  It does not.  It never did.  Donald John Trump said Mexico would pay for the wall at campaign rallies between 2015 and 2016 because it played well to audiences who had never looked at a map of North America properly.  Mexico’s then-president, Enrique Peña Nieto, told Trump publicly that Mexico would not pay.  Trump responded by cancelling a scheduled meeting.  That, in diplomatic terms, is what losing an argument looks like.

The more useful question is whether Mexico could have been made to pay indirectly — through tariffs, NAFTA renegotiation, or remittance fees.  Trump’s own budget director, John Michael “Mick” Mulvaney, acknowledged in 2019 that the Department of Homeland Security “cannot spend money from Mexico.”  The NAFTA successor agreement, the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement, produced no mechanism for wall funding.  Seven years after the promise, Mexico paid for zero metres of wall.  The promise was always theatre.

The Numbers are Fictional

Five billion dollars was not an estimate.  It was a number Trump chose because it sounded large enough to be serious and small enough to seem achievable.  It bore no relationship to actual construction costs.  During Trump’s first term, CBP’s own figures put the cost at US$20 million per mile.  The Bush-era fence cost US$4 million per mile.  A full wall across all 1,954 miles of the US-Mexico border — accounting for terrain, land acquisition, legal challenges, and infrastructure — was estimated by the Centre for American Progress at US$70 billion.  The Massachusetts Institute of Technology put it at US$38 billion.  Nobody credible put it anywhere near US$5 billion.

Congress has since approved US$46.5 billion for the current expansion.  As of January 2026, the Trump administration had completed just over twenty-seven miles of new barrier in its second term — at 0.2 miles per day.  In the six months before June 2026, the Department of Homeland Security awarded US$19.4 billion in border wall contracts.  Fisher Sand & Gravel alone received US$7.8 billion.  Barnard Construction received US$4.5 billion.  Five other companies received contracts of US$1 billion or more each.  93 per cent of all border wall spending in the past decade occurred in 2025 and 2026.  That is not a wall.  That is a construction industry subsidy programme with a fence attached.

The Wall Does Not Solve the Problem

A significant proportion of undocumented immigrants in the United States did not cross the southern border illegally.  They entered legally on valid visas and overstayed.  A 2019 Centre for Migration Studies report found that visa overstays outnumbered illegal crossings for seven consecutive years.  In that study, overstays accounted for 62 per cent of newly undocumented residents, against 38 per cent who crossed without authorisation.

A wall addresses nothing about airports, seaports, cargo containers, or the bureaucratic tracking failures that allow legal visitors to disappear into American society.  It is a solution to a problem that constitutes well under half of the issue it claims to fix.  Then there are the tunnels.  Joaquín Archivaldo Guzmán Loera — better known as El Chapo — pioneered the use of cross-border tunnels to move contraband into the United States.  The first known tunnel, sixty metres long, linked Agua Prieta in Sonora to Douglas, Arizona, in 1990.  By the time of his arrest in 2016, the model had been refined considerably.  Recent cartel tunnels run three hundred metres long and twenty-five metres deep.  They feature steel reinforcement, electric lighting, ventilation systems, and rail-mounted carts.  US Ambassador Kenneth Lee Salazar estimated over two hundred smuggling tunnels in the Tijuana–San Diego corridor alone.  Border Patrol has discovered at least 230 cross-border tunnels since 1990.  Those are only the ones they found.  The cartels did not look at Trump’s wall and despair.  They looked at it and ordered more shovels.  One drug haul found in a tunnel running under new border wall construction was valued at US$30 million.  The wall had been standing for months.

Political Architecture

Trump’s wall was not a border security policy.  It was a political identity marker.  “Build the wall” was a chant, not a specification.  Its value to Trump was totemic — proof he could impose his will on a system that had previously dismissed him.  Giving him the money was indistinguishable, from the Democrats’ perspective, from ratifying his entire political identity.  Their base would not have forgiven it.

The shutdown lasted 35 days — the longest in US history, at that point.  It cost the US economy an estimated US$11 billion, according to the Congressional Budget Office.  Trump eventually signed a continuing resolution that contained US$1.375 billion for border barriers — not a wall, not US$5 billion, not anything approaching what he demanded.  He then declared a national emergency to redirect military construction funds, triggering years of litigation.  He got less than a third of what he asked for, through a mechanism the courts spent years challenging, after inflicting US$11 billion in economic damage on his own country to make the point.  Tremendous deal-making.

The Problem with the Question

The question contains an embedded assumption that America’s immigration problems are primarily caused by people crossing the southern border, that those people are primarily Mexican, and that a physical barrier is a proportionate and effective response.  All three assumptions are wrong.  The top nationalities for visa overstays in recent years have included Canadians, Brazilians, Colombians, Venezuelans, and Indians — not Mexicans.  The southern border wall is not even targeted at the right demographic by nationality.

A Canadian wall would capture more overstays by volume.  Nobody proposes a Canadian wall, because the political constituency for one does not exist, and because the Canadian government would respond with the kind of measured diplomatic fury that does not make for good rally chants.  How would Americans feel if Canada erected a multibillion-dollar barrier to keep Americans out?  The question answers itself.

As of 2026, the United States has awarded US$20 billion in border wall contracts in under two years of Trump’s second term.  It has completed twenty-seven miles of new barrier since January 2025.  The cartels continue to tunnel.  The visa overstay population continues to grow.  The immigration courts remain backlogged by years.  The wall is the most expensive fence in human history, built to honour a campaign promise that was always structurally incoherent, funded by American taxpayers rather than Mexico, and effective against the fraction of undocumented immigration it was advertised to solve.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.