20 April, 2020

Quora Answer: What Do Singaporeans Think about Forced Multiculturalism in Singapore?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “What do Singaporeans think about forced multiculturalism in Singapore?”

You cannot force multiculturalism on a city-state that was multicultural before it had a government.  That is like forcing the tide to be wet.  The question is not whether multiculturalism exists here.  The question is whether we are managing it well — and whether we are candid about what we have yet to fix.

Singapore’s total resident population stands at 4.2 million, of whom 3.66 million are citizens and 540,000 are permanent residents.  The ethnic breakdown has been stable for decades: Chinese, 75.5 per cent; Malay, 15.1 per cent; Indian, 7.6 per cent; Eurasians and others, 1.8 per cent.  Non-residents — a category that now represents 48.7 per cent of people physically present in Singapore — are not classified under the ethnic system at all.  So, Singapore is simultaneously an ancient trading entrepôt where multiple civilisations have coexisted for centuries, and a country where nearly half the people living here on any given day do not officially register as part of that multicultural story.  The gap between the narrative and the arithmetic is wide enough to drive a container ship through.

The official story is that multiculturalism is organic.  Ethnic communities arrived, settled, traded, and built institutions.  The Chinese came primarily from Fujian and Guangdong.  The Indians came from Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, and Sri Lanka.  The Malays were the original inhabitants of the archipelago, supplemented by later migration from Sumatra, Java, and the Riau islands.  The Eurasians are a broad grouping — the descendants of Asians and the various European colonial powers: Portuguese, Dutch, British, Spanish, and others.  My own community, the Kristang, are specifically the descendants of the Portuguese who conquered and administered Malacca from 1511.  They are the remnant of a colonial society, with its own internal hierarchy: the Upper Ten, the fidalgo and royal houses; the Lower Ten, the minor nobility and clergy; and below them, the common people.  That community settled in Singapore following the British takeover of Malacca in 1824.

The CMIO Box

The British colonial administration needed to count people.  It imposed the Chinese-Malay-Indian-Others framework in 1956.  Singapore inherited it at independence.  It has been the administrative spine of race policy ever since.  The framework is a bureaucratic convenience dressed up as a cultural fact.  Singaporeans are registered under more than 200 distinct ethnic identities, all of which are collapsed into four boxes for administrative purposes.  Hokkien, Cantonese, Teochew, and Hakka become “Chinese.”  Javanese, Bugis, Boyanese, and Minangkabau become “Malay.”  Tamil, Malayali, Punjabi, and Sinhalese become “Indian.”  My community, the Portuguese-descended Kristang, the Armenian merchants, the Jewish families whose ancestors built the Maghain Aboth synagogue on Waterloo Street, the Eurasians of Dutch and British extraction — all of us become “Others.”

The government has claimed that the CMIO framework does not prescribe one’s racial identity, but helps them to administer race-based policies.  That is a circular argument.  The framework exists to administer policies that exist because the framework exists.  The CMIO system has served to homogenise social groups and eliminate the diversity and heterogeneity within them.  When the government closed dialect radio stations in the 1980s to promote Mandarin as the official language of the Chinese community, it erased a rich linguistic heritage — Hokkien, Cantonese, Teochew — shared by the majority of ethnic Chinese Singaporeans, whose ancestral languages were not Mandarin.  Multiculturalism was alive.  Official policy silenced it.  The four-box system made sense as a starting point in 1956.  It is a poor description of Singapore in 2026.

Policies & Their Consequences

The Ethnic Integration Policy governs HDB resale flat transactions.  Each housing block and neighbourhood must maintain ethnic proportions within defined limits, pegged broadly to the national ethnic breakdown.  A Chinese family seeking to sell in a block that has reached its Chinese quota cannot sell to another Chinese buyer.  They must sell to a Malay or Indian buyer instead.  This policy has been in place since 1989.  Its stated purpose is to prevent racial enclaves.  Its actual function is to override the revealed preferences of the population and engineer outcomes the state considers desirable.  Whether those outcomes are good is a separate question from whether they are managed.  They are, unambiguously, managed.  Singapore is a small, densely populated, ethnically complex city-state surrounded by neighbours who have, at various points in history, used ethnicity as a political lever.  The 1964 racial riots, instigated in part by external actors, demonstrated that Singapore’s diversity is a vulnerability as much as a strength.  Residential engineering that prevents the formation of ethnic enclaves reduces the surface area for that kind of exploitation.  The EIP is blunt.  It is also rational.

The Group Representation Constituency system ensures that parliamentary teams include at least one minority candidate — Malay, Indian, or Other — per multi-member constituency.  The purpose is to guarantee minority representation in Parliament.  The side effect is that opposition parties must field ethnically diverse slates, which is structurally harder when talent pools are smaller.  This has been used as a tool to shield anchor ministers in safe seats by pairing them with minority candidates under the GRC umbrella, with the effect that the minority candidate rides in on the majority’s coattails rather than on the community’s mandate.  We have had some awful minority candidates.

The Maintenance of Racial Harmony Act, passed by Parliament on 4th February 2025 and in force from September 2026, gives the Minister for Home Affairs the power to issue Restraining Orders against individuals for content that prejudices racial harmony.  Those orders take effect immediately, before any judicial process, and can prohibit a person from addressing certain audiences or holding editorial roles.  Violations carry up to three years’ imprisonment for repeat offenders.  Racial and religious incitement is not abstract in Singapore.  External actors — state and non-state — have targeted this country’s ethnic fault lines before, and they will do so again.  Legislation that gives the government a rapid-response tool against destabilising speech is a reasonable instrument for a country in Singapore’s position.  The objection is not to the tool.  It is to the assumption that the tool will always be used proportionately and without political convenience.  That assumption requires oversight, and oversight requires a press and judiciary that can exercise it.

The Data

Singapore presents itself to the world as a model of multicultural harmony.  Racial Harmony Day is celebrated every 21st July.  Schoolchildren wear each other’s traditional costumes.  Politicians speak warmly about being one people.  Then there is the data.  A 2024 survey of 4,000 Singaporeans by the Institute of Policy Studies and OnePeople.sg found that 18.4 per cent of Malay respondents had experienced racial discrimination in a job application or promotion.  The figure for Indian respondents was 16.7 per cent.  For Chinese respondents, it was 3.7 per cent.  In the same survey, 23.7 per cent of Malay respondents and 23.4 per cent of Indian respondents reported frequent day-to-day discrimination in the workplace.  For Chinese respondents, the figure was 6 per cent.  The state’s response is to pass a Workplace Fairness Bill, also in January 2025, and to run diversity programmes using “interactive gaming tools.”  The gap between the magnitude of the problem and the gentleness of the response is not reassuring.

Meanwhile, support for keeping the CMIO framework unchanged has grown.  The same IPS survey found that 58.1 per cent of respondents in 2024 supported no change to CMIO — up from 46.2 per cent in 2018.  The majority of Singaporeans have concluded that the box they were born into is worth preserving.  This is what a framework that has been in place for 70 years does to a population: it makes the box feel natural.

The People Who Fall Through the Framework

My community is a useful case study.  The Kristang are the descendants of the Portuguese who conquered and administered Malacca from 1511.  Theirs was not a merchant community that happened to settle — it was a colonial society, with the full internal stratification that implies: the Upper Ten, the fidalgo and royal houses; the Lower Ten, the minor nobility and clergy; and below them, the common people.  That society maintained its own creole language — Kristang — its own Catholic religious traditions, and its own distinct cultural practices across five centuries.  Following the British takeover of Malacca in 1824, significant numbers settled in Singapore.  They are one strand within the broader Eurasian community, which also includes descendants of Dutch, British, Spanish, and other European lineages mixed with Asian heritage.  Today, the Kristang number a few thousand in Singapore, the majority elderly.  The language is listed as critically endangered.  The community is classified as “Others” in the CMIO administrative system — a category that also contains Armenians, Jews, Germans, Filipinos, Thais, and anyone else who does not fit neatly into the Chinese, Malay, or Indian box.

The government has, to its credit, recognised the Eurasian community as a distinct entity in one important respect.  In 1994, the Eurasian Association was formally designated as a Self-Help Group, placing it on the same institutional footing as the Chinese Development Assistance Council, Mendaki, and SINDA.  Every CPF-contributing employee contributes to one of these four funds based on race.  The Eurasian Community Fund exists alongside the other three in statute.  Former Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, speaking at the Eurasian Association’s centenary, described the 1994 designation as formal government acknowledgement that “notwithstanding your community’s size, you are an important part of Singapore.”

That recognition is real.  It is also incomplete.  The Self-Help Group structure gives the Eurasian community institutional standing.  It does not give it CMIO standing.  Under the ethnic quota system that governs HDB flat transactions, Eurasians fall under the "Indian and Others" category — grouped with everyone else who does not fit the three primary boxes.  There is no Eurasian quota.  There is no Eurasian parliamentary seat.  Formal recognition, in other words, has a ceiling.  The Eurasian Association remains structurally the smallest and least resourced of the four self-help groups.  The Kristang language receives no state funding to speak of.  It is disappearing on the government’s watch, in a country that brands itself as a celebration of cultural diversity.

CDAC, Mendaki, SINDA, and the Eurasian Association serve a real function: they direct community resources toward educational and social uplift within communities that have different starting conditions.  The model is not the problem.  The problem is that the model does not go far enough.  Singapore has more than 200 registered ethnic identities.  The Kristang are not the only community at risk.  A framework that funds four groups and ignores the rest is a framework that has decided cultural preservation is worth funding selectively, not universally.  If Singapore believes in the multiculturalism it advertises, it should fund the preservation of ethnic heritage beyond the four CMIO boxes.  Language programmes.  Cultural archives.  Community arts funding.  The cost is modest.  The statement it makes is not.

The Malay-Muslim Conflation Problem

There is a structural fault in Singapore’s management of its Muslim community that the government has not adequately addressed.  The conflation of Malay ethnicity with Muslim religious identity is pervasive in Singapore’s institutional architecture.  MENDAKI, formally Yayasan Mendaki, is designated as the self-help group for the "Malay/Muslim community."  Its mandate is ethnic as much as religious.  The Mosque Building and Mendaki Fund — the MBMF — collects contributions from all Muslim employees in Singapore, regardless of ethnicity.  An Indian Muslim, a Chinese Muslim, a Eurasian convert — all contribute monthly through CPF.  They contribute to a fund whose Mendaki component serves a community defined by ethnicity, not by faith.

MUIS, the Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura, is the statutory body that administers Muslim law, oversees mosques, manages zakat and waqf, and governs madrasah education.  Its mandate under the Administration of Muslim Law Act is defined in terms of Muslims.  In practice, the overlap between the Muslim population and the Malay ethnic community in Singapore is so extensive — 98 per cent of Malays are Muslim — that the institutions have fused in the public mind and in the administrative architecture.  The consequence is that minority Muslims — Indian Muslims, Chinese Muslims, Eurasian converts, Muslim migrants from non-Malay backgrounds — exist in a gap.  They contribute to the MBMF.  Their access to Mendaki’s programmes is conditional on eligibility criteria that are not transparently published.  They fund an institution whose cultural centre of gravity is Malay.  They are, in some meaningful sense, paying for a community they are not part of.

We have a Malay community that takes advantage of the converts to Islam to fund their own programmes.  It is a criticism of an administrative architecture that has allowed ethnicity and religion to become synonymous in a way that disadvantages the minority within the minority.  A Muslim convert from a Chinese family contributes to Mendaki through the MBMF.  He may also contribute to CDAC through his registered race.  He receives full access to neither.  He is doubly taxed and partially served.  Singapore does not have a satisfactory answer to this.  The fix is not complicated.  MENDAKI should serve Muslims.  The MBMF should fund Muslim welfare, not Malay welfare.  MUIS already has the statutory mandate to do this.  Institutional architecture should follow the mandate, not the ethnicity.  Singapore’s Muslim community has become more ethnically diverse.  Its institutions have not kept pace.

The Case for a Post-Racial Civil Service

There is one area where the managed multiculturalism model has outlived its usefulness, and where Singapore can and should move faster.  Civil and statutory appointments — Permanent Secretaries, Heads of Statutory Boards, senior public servants — should be made on merit.  The government has been cautious about articulating this, in part because the optics of saying “race no longer matters in appointments” are complicated in a country where the data show that race very much still matters in employment outcomes.  But the caution is counterproductive.  The continued informal practice of ethnic balancing in senior appointments — the expectation that representatives of particular communities will hold certain positions — does not serve merit.  It reinforces the idea that ethnic identity is a relevant qualification for public office.

Singapore has demonstrated that it can produce leaders of extraordinary quality from every ethnic community.  The country does not need a quota system at the top of its civil service.  What it needs is a meritocracy that is blind to ethnicity at the point of appointment, backed by interventions at the bottom — in education, in early-childhood development, in economic opportunity — that ensure every community has the platform to compete.  The GRC system in its current form is an obstacle to that aspiration.  Guaranteeing minority representation in Parliament through a team-based system that reduces individual accountability is not the same as producing minority leaders who have earned a mandate from their own constituencies.  Singapore should move towards single-member constituencies with reserved seats rotated across ethnic categories, so that minority MPs win on their own merits rather than in the shadow of a GRC anchor.  That is a harder political reform.  It is worth having.

What is Multiculturalism in Singapore?

It is three things simultaneously, and it is important not to confuse them.

It is organic at the street level.  Singaporeans of different ethnicities eat together, work together, live beside each other, and form families across ethnic lines.  The intermarriage trend is upward.  In 2023, 2,326 children of mixed parentage were registered with double-barrelled races.  The social reality of Singapore is one of real and deep intercommunal familiarity.

It is managed at the policy level.  The HDB ethnic quota, the GRC system, the designated self-help groups, the government-sanctioned language hierarchies — these are deliberate interventions designed to produce outcomes the state has decided are desirable.  I support the principle of managed multiculturalism.  Singapore is too small, too diverse, and too exposed to external interference to treat social cohesion as self-maintaining.  But management requires candour about what is being managed, and why.  Some of what passes for management is engineering.  Some of it is ethnic politics dressed as social policy.  Those two things are not the same.

It is policed at the speech level.  The Maintenance of Racial Harmony Act gives the government a tool for rapid intervention against destabilising speech.  I support that tool.  The concern is not the existence of the legislation.  It is whether the oversight mechanisms are strong enough to ensure it is used for the purpose stated, and not for the purpose of silencing inconvenient critics.  Singapore’s answer to that concern is not yet fully convincing.

The Assessment

Singapore did not invent multiculturalism.  It inherited it.  The variety of peoples who live on this island is the product of geography and trade, not government planning.  The British created the administrative structure.  The People’s Action Party inherited and deepened it.  What Singapore has built is a system that simultaneously celebrates diversity and constrains it — that places cultural communities in administrative boxes, funds them unequally, engineers their residential distribution, and manages discourse it considers destabilising.  Then it declares this a model for the world.

The model works, by some measures.  Singapore has not had a racial riot since 1969.  Inter-ethnic trust, while imperfect, is higher here than in most comparable societies.  The country functions.  The managed approach to multiculturalism has produced a more stable society than the alternative might have.  I accept that argument.  But accepting the argument does not require accepting the current implementation as final.  Singapore can do more to preserve the cultural heritage of communities that fall outside the four CMIO boxes.  It can separate ethnicity from religion in its institutional architecture, so that minority Muslims are not disadvantaged by an administrative assumption that Muslim means Malay.  It can move towards a post-racial framework for senior civil and statutory appointments.  It can reform the GRC system to produce minority parliamentarians who hold mandates earned on their own terms.

None of these reforms requires dismantling what works.  They require extending its logic to communities and individuals the current system serves incompletely.  Singapore likes to present itself as a finished product.  It is not.  It is a country that has done extraordinarily well with an imperfect set of tools — and that is capable of doing better.  The question is whether it is willing to have that conversation.  The Maintenance of Racial Harmony Act does not answer that question.  It defers it.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.