09 January, 2020

Bishan Toastmasters Club: Stress, Perception, & a Dash of Poe

On 26th November 2019, I was at Bishan Toastmasters Club as Language Evaluator, my 127th club visit on the 149th day of the Toastmaster year.  Kokul Raj served as Sergeant-at-Arms.  Kanchan Mendis served as Toastmaster of the Day.  Chen Li Ming served as Timer.  Winnie Chong served as Ah Counter.  Rakesh Kethineedi served as Table Topics Master.

A Roast with Affection

Sophia Ngo opened her President’s address with a roast of Celine Goh, delivered as a self-deprecating accolade coated in affection.  A roast that lands warmly rather than cruelly is a harder speech to write than it appears, since the effect depends on the audience trusting the affection underneath the barbs before a single joke is told.

Stress, Reframed Correctly

Tuyen spoke on the effects of stress, arguing it is not stress itself that affects us, but our reaction to it.  This is not merely a motivational turn of phrase.  Dr. Richard S. Lazarus and Dr. Susan Folkman’s transactional model of stress, published in 1984, remains one of the most cited frameworks in psychology because it makes this claim empirically: stress arises from an individual’s cognitive appraisal of a situation relative to their perceived ability to cope with it, not from the stimulus in isolation.  Tuyen’s own life illustrated the model directly.  Her family moved from Vietnam to France while she was still in primary school, and she was initially reticent in an unfamiliar language and culture.  As her mastery of French grew, her confidence grew with it, eventually carrying her into a career as a lawyer.  She has since moved to Singapore and is now working on mastering English, applying the identical strategy that already carried her across one language barrier to the next.

Passion with a Boundary Attached

Chaudhary spoke on following his passion for electronics, and the challenges of working in a technical role inside a trading house, where his specialism was not always the organisation’s central priority.  His advice ran counter to the usual “follow your passion at all costs” cliché: pursue what interests you, but keep time reserved for yourself regardless.  A passion pursued without boundary tends to consume the person pursuing it, and Chaudhary’s caveat is the part most passion-driven advice conveniently omits.

Truth, Perception, and an Old Parable

Nino Yap argued that truth is limited by our perception, illustrating the point through the well-known parable of the blind men and the elephant, each man’s description of the animal shaped by the single part he happened to touch.  The parable’s most famous English rendering comes from the American poet John Godfrey Saxe in the nineteenth century, though its roots trace back further into South Asian religious and philosophical tradition.  Yap’s framing centred on the distinction between absolute and relative truth, an old philosophical fault line, and one no amount of confident assertion resolves on its own.

A Reading from Poe

Sajeev Kumar read an extract from Edgar Allan Poe’s Loss of Breath, a satirical short story first published in 1832 under the title A Decided Loss, in which the narrator loses the physical ability to breathe partway through an argument with his wife and spends the remainder of the tale attempting to survive without it.  Reading Poe aloud in a Toastmasters meeting is a bold choice.  His prose was built for the page, dense and ornate by modern standards, and delivering it aloud with the pacing and gravity it demands is a harder exercise than reading a contemporary passage written for the ear rather than the eye.

The Evaluators and Results

Ernie Khoo, Suresh, and Linda Zhang served as Project Evaluators.  Best Speaker went to Tuyen.  Best Evaluator went to Suresh.  Best Table Topics Speaker went to a guest.  A meeting spanning cognitive psychology, ancient parable, career advice, and nineteenth-century American gothic fiction within a single hour is not a small range for one club to cover convincingly, and this one managed it without a single speech feeling out of place beside the others.


Terence Nunis, DTM | Division Advisor, District 80 Division M | Club Advisor, AIA Toastmasters | Past President & Founder, Awesome Toastmasters

































No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.