09 November, 2019

Bukit Batok Toastmasters Club: A Journey From Coleridge to Existentialism in One Meeting

On 2nd November 2019, I was at Bukit Batok Toastmasters Club as Toastmaster of the Day, my 105th club visit on the 125th day of the Toastmaster year.  Julia Pan served as Sergeant-at-Arms.  Annie Goh, DMT, served as Table Topics Master.  Sathiyavani Muthu served as Timer.  John Liew served as Workshop Speaker.

A Journey Built from Words Alone

John Liew brought us on a magical journey using only words, drawing on excerpts of The Rime of the Ancient Mariner to demonstrate the power of language to paint a picture without a single visual aid.  Samuel Taylor Coleridge published the poem in 1798 as part of Lyrical Ballads, co-authored with William Wordsworth, and its imagery – an albatross shot dead for no reason, a ship becalmed under a copper sky, “water, water, everywhere, nor any drop to drink” has survived over two centuries because the language does the work a camera never could.  Liew’s choice of source material was not incidental.  It was a demonstration that the oldest technology for moving an audience remains the sentence itself.

An Existentialist Icebreaker

Lucy Koh gave her icebreaker speech, stating she will not be defined by her titles or her relationships, an existentialist monologue in substance, not merely in label.  Jean-Paul Sartre’s own formulation, that existence precedes essence, argues that a person is not born with a fixed nature determined by role or relationship, but instead defines himself through the choices he makes across a lifetime.  Delivering that philosophical position as a first speech, rather than the standard “here is my job and my family” introduction most icebreakers default to, is a bolder opening than most speakers attempt on their debut.

A Letter to a Younger Self

Mellita Angga read from a letter she wrote to her younger self during a period of hardship, offering words of comfort while detailing the loneliness, insecurity, and fear she experienced on first arriving in Singapore.  A foreigner in a foreign land, she spoke of the slow work of adapting and rebuilding a social network from nothing.  It was an uplifting story, carrying a great many lessons for everyone in the room, because it refused to skip the difficult middle chapters on the way to the happy ending.

Communication as a Living Process

Vanitha spoke on the process of communication, defining it as a dynamic process that makes or breaks relationships, and stressing that communication is never simply about the words chosen, but how they are deployed.  This tracks closely with Dr. Claude Elwood Shannon and Dr. Warren Weaver’s foundational 1948 model of communication, which framed the process as a continuous exchange between sender, message, channel, and receiver, vulnerable to distortion at every stage rather than a single clean transmission of meaning.  Vanitha’s own framing, communication as something that actively makes or breaks a relationship rather than a neutral exchange, updates that decades-old model with the emotional stakes any working communicator must manage.

The Evaluators and Results

Tony Lim, DTM, Vincent An, Tony Tan, Lim Chang Jing, DTM, and Martinn Ho served as Project Evaluators.  Best Speaker went to Mellita Angga.  Best Evaluator went to Vincent Chua.  Best Table Topics Speaker went to Tan Sze Yong.  A meeting running from an eighteenth-century poem to Sartrean philosophy to the mechanics of evaluation itself is not a modest range for one club to cover in a single evening, and this one covered it without a single transition feeling forced.


Terence Nunis, DTM | Division Advisor, District 80 Division M | Club Advisor, AIA Toastmasters | Past President & Founder, Awesome Toastmasters








No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.