27 August, 2020

Quora Answer: Is It Possible for Singapore to Reclaim Land All the Way to Pedra Branca?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “Is it possible for Singapore to reclaim land all the way to Pedra Branca, without intruding into Malaysian or Indonesian waters?”

No, Singapore cannot reclaim land all the way to Pedra Branca.  The reasons span international law, engineering physics, diplomatic reality, and basic common sense — in roughly that order.

Start with the geography.  Pedra Branca is almost 24 nautical miles east of Singapore’s main island, Pulau Ujung.  One nautical mile is 1.852 kilometres, placing the island 44 kilometres from our baseline.  The 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, to which Singapore is a signatory, grants territorial waters up to 12 nautical miles from that baseline.  Pedra Branca lies well outside that zone.  The intervening waters belong — in overlapping and contested claims — to Malaysia and Indonesia.

The International Court of Justice awarded sovereignty over Pedra Branca to Singapore in 2008.  Malaysia initially sought to revise that ruling, then withdrew the application.  The window for revision closed in May 2018.  As of January 2025, Singapore’s Minister for Foreign Affairs Dr Vivian Balakrishnan confirmed that a Malaysia-Singapore Joint Technical Committee continues working through outstanding bilateral matters, including maritime boundary delimitation.  The sovereignty question is settled.  The boundary question is not.

The Legal Barrier

Which brings us to the reclamation proposal.  Reclamation does not automatically extend territorial waters.  Under UNCLOS, artificial islands and structures do not generate territorial seas.  Article 60 of the Convention is unambiguous on this point.  If Singapore were to reclaim land in waters that Malaysia or Indonesia claims — which all the waters between Singapore and Pedra Branca are — it would constitute a unilateral act in disputed territory.  This is not a bureaucratic technicality.  It is the kind of act that ends up back at the ICJ, accompanied by a great deal of diplomatic unpleasantness that Singapore’s trade-dependent economy cannot afford.  Innocent passage through these littoral waters is guaranteed under UNCLOS.  The right to pour sand into them is not.

The Engineering Barrier

Singapore has reclaimed 25 per cent of its current land area since independence, expanding from 581.5 square kilometres in 1965 to around 734 square kilometres today.  The reclamation costs for projects completed in the past decade ran between S$270 and S$850 per square metre.  Singapore’s proposed Long Island project — a relatively modest reclamation off the East Coast covering 8 million square metres — already presents significant engineering challenges in deeper water than any previous East Coast project.  Indonesia banned sand exports to Singapore in 2007.  Malaysia followed in 2018.  The primary raw material for reclamation is therefore no longer available from the two countries that surround Singapore’s waters.

Now scale that problem across 44 kilometres of open sea, in waters that deepen as you move east toward Pedra Branca, against an active current, with no legal right to be there.  Reclaimed land in that environment would require a continuous causeway or a series of artificial islands — each one an engineering project of extraordinary complexity, each one subject to soil settlement that takes a minimum of a decade before any structure can be built on it.  The cost would be measured in hundreds of billions of dollars.  The diplomatic cost would be incalculable.

The Shipping Lane Problem

The Singapore Strait carries the Traffic Separation Scheme — the IMO-mandated system of separated shipping lanes that governs one of the world’s most congested waterways.  In 2025, the Malacca and Singapore Straits recorded 102,525 transits of vessels above 300 gross tonnes — the first year the figure crossed 100,000, representing an 8.72 per cent increase from the 94,301 transits recorded in 2024.  At current rates, 281 vessels per day report to Klang VTS.  That includes 28 deeply laden vessels per day with draughts exceeding 15 metres — ultra-large container vessels and very large crude carriers that have virtually no margin for navigational error.

The TSS runs 250 nautical miles from One Fathom Bank off Port Klang to Horsburgh Lighthouse on Pedra Branca itself.  At its narrowest point, just south of St John’s Island, the westbound lane is 530 metres wide.  Any reclamation project in the eastern Singapore Strait would directly intrude into those lanes.  Diverting 100,000 annual transits — including tankers carrying a major share of the world’s crude oil supply — is not a planning inconvenience.  It is a global trade disruption with consequences Singapore would bear disproportionately.

Singapore’s economic model rests on the free, predictable, unimpeded movement of cargo through its waters.  The port handled a record 40 million twenty-foot equivalent units in 2024.  The proposal to reclaim land across the shipping lanes serving that port is the maritime equivalent of building a motorway across Changi Airport’s runway.

The Verdict

The idea of connecting it to Singapore by reclamation is an entertaining thought experiment that collapses on contact with international law, engineering reality, material supply constraints, and the fundamental interests of every shipping company, port, and oil-importing nation on earth.  Some ambitions are best expressed as questions on Quora rather than as policy proposals.  This is a stupid idea.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.