The following is my answer to a Quora
question: “How
well does Toastmasters develop your interpersonal skills?”
The question assumes that public speaking
and interpersonal skills are the same thing.
They are not. A person can be an
outstanding orator and a genuinely terrible human being to work with. Toastmasters produces both categories. The programme has 270,000 members across more
than 14,200 clubs worldwide as of 2025.
A significant proportion of those members have been attending meetings
for years, have accumulated ribbons and certificates, and remain as socially
difficult as they were on the day they joined.
The speaking improved. The person
did not.
The Gymnasium Membership Problem
Toastmasters is useful in proportion to
the seriousness with which a member engages it.
This is true of every developmental programme — but it is especially
true here because the programme is self-paced, voluntary, and entirely
dependent on the member choosing to take up the opportunities it provides. Most members do not. They attend meetings. They deliver the minimum required
speeches. They applaud others. They collect their ribbons. They describe themselves on LinkedIn as
Toastmasters members and cite it as evidence of communication skills. They have developed neither communication
skills nor interpersonal skills to any material degree.
The psychological research on skill
development is unambiguous on this point.
Professor Karl Anders Ericsson of Florida State University — whose work
on deliberate practice is the most cited in the field — established that mere
exposure to an activity produces negligible skill development. The mechanism of improvement is deliberate
practice: structured repetition with immediate feedback, progressively
increasing difficulty, and conscious attention to the specific elements
requiring improvement. Attending a
Toastmasters meeting without speaking, evaluating, or holding a role is
exposure. It is not deliberate
practice. It produces nothing.
The Speaking-Leadership Distinction
Public speaking trains a specific
competency: the ability to organise thought, structure argument, and deliver it
coherently to an audience. This is
valuable. It is not interpersonal
competence. The psychological mechanisms
underlying them are different. Public
speaking is a performance skill — it is developed in conditions of relative
control, where the speaker manages the content, the timing, and the framing of
their communication. The audience is
largely passive. The speaker’s
performance is evaluated against their own preparation.
Interpersonal competence operates in
conditions of dynamic uncertainty. Dr John
Mordechai Gottman, Professor Emeritus of Psychology at the University of
Washington — whose decades of research on interpersonal relationships produced
a predictive model for relationship outcomes accurate to approximately 91 per
cent — identified that interpersonal competence depends on the ability to
manage physiological arousal during conflict, read the emotional states of
others, and respond to bids for connection rather than dismissing them. None of these capacities is developed through
speech delivery.
Dr Daniel Jay Goleman’s framework of
emotional intelligence — published in 1995 and subsequently validated through
meta-analyses covering more than 500 studies — identifies five components:
self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation, empathy, and social skills. Of these five, public speaking training
addresses primarily self-awareness and motivation in the specific context of
performance. It does not address
self-regulation under relational stress, empathy as a practised capacity, or
the social skills that operate in informal, unstructured interactions. The Toastmasters member who has delivered
fifty speeches has repeatedly practised self-awareness and motivation in a
controlled performance setting. They
have not necessarily practised any of the other three components.
The Leadership Roles: Where
Interpersonal Development Occurs
Interpersonal skills — the ability to read
a room, manage conflict, build trust, give difficult feedback without
destroying a relationship, motivate people who are not obliged to follow you,
and navigate competing interests toward a shared outcome — are developed
through leadership practice. The
psychological basis for this is established by Dr Albert Bandura OC, David
Starr Jordan Professor Emeritus of Social Science in Psychology at Stanford
University of Stanford University, whose Social Learning Theory identifies that
complex social skills are acquired through observation, modelling, and enactive
mastery — learning by doing in a social context with feedback from others. A Toastmasters officer role provides this
structure: a defined leadership responsibility, a team context, regular
feedback through club and district performance metrics, and the consequence of
actual outcomes for real people.
The Vice President of Education, who runs
a club’s educational programme, has navigated scheduling conflicts, managed
reluctant members, motivated speakers who cancelled at the last minute, and
delivered a programme against defined District metrics. These are not simulated leadership
challenges. They are real ones with real
consequences — a club that fails to achieve Distinguished status, a member who
leaves because the programme did not serve them, a contest that runs poorly
because logistics were mismanaged.
The research on leadership development
through role-holding is consistent.
Professor Morgan W. McCall Jr. of the University of Southern California,
whose research on executive development identified that 70 per cent of
leadership learning occurs through challenging job assignments and stretch
experiences — not through training programmes or feedback alone. The Toastmasters officer role is a stretch
experience. The speech project is a
training programme. The distinction in
developmental mechanism is fundamental.
The Feedback Mechanism: Why
Evaluation Develops Interpersonal Skill
The evaluation process in Toastmasters —
giving and receiving structured feedback on speeches — is where the programme’s
interpersonal development potential is highest, and where most members
underinvest. Dr Carol Susan Dweck, Lewis
and Virginia Eaton Professor of Psychology at Stanford University, whose
research on mindset established the growth mindset framework, found that the
ability to receive critical feedback without defensiveness is one of the
primary differentiators between high and low development trajectories. Individuals with a fixed mindset — who
interpret criticism as a verdict on their fixed abilities — avoid feedback,
disengage from challenging environments, and plateau early. Individuals with a growth mindset treat
feedback as information and actively seek it.
A Toastmasters member who has given fifty
evaluations and received fifty has practised both sides of this dynamic —
delivering critical observation constructively and receiving it without
defensiveness — in a low-stakes environment designed to make the practice
safe. This is a rare developmental
opportunity. Most professional
environments do not provide structured feedback on communication with the
regularity and specificity that a Toastmasters evaluation provides. The member who declines to evaluate others,
and who deflects feedback on their own speeches, has avoided the mechanism
through which the programme develops interpersonal skills. They have attended the gymnasium and sat in
the changing room.
The Mentoring Relationship
Pathways formalises the mentoring
relationship through the Mentor Programme.
The developmental psychology of mentoring is well established. Mentored individuals reported higher career
satisfaction, greater organisational commitment, and stronger interpersonal
competence than non-mentored counterparts.
The effect was strongest where the mentoring relationship involved
regular interaction, specific skill feedback, and psychological safety. A Toastmasters mentor who successfully guides
a new member through their first speeches and first officer role has practised
the specific interpersonal competencies that the mentoring literature
identifies as developmental: patience calibrated to an individual’s pace rather
than the mentor’s preference, feedback adjusted to the mentee’s specific
developmental needs rather than a generic template, and the ability to build a
trust-based relationship with a person who has no obligation to accept
guidance. None of this occurs in a
speech competition.
The Contest Winner Failure Mode
The failure mode is consistent across
clubs. A member joins, discovers they
enjoy the performance of public speaking, pursues speeches and contests with
enthusiasm, and avoids officer roles because officer roles are administrative,
unglamorous, and require managing other people’s problems. This member improves as a speaker. They do not improve as a leader or as a
person in relationship with others.
After five years in Toastmasters, they are a better speaker and the same
colleague, subordinate, or superior they were on the day they joined.
The psychological explanation is
straightforward. Research on performance
motivation — particularly Self-Determination Theory — identifies that intrinsic
motivation toward a specific activity produces mastery of that activity, not
transfer of skill to adjacent domains. A
person intrinsically motivated to perform well as a speaker will develop their
speaking. They will not automatically
develop their leadership or interpersonal competence unless they are also
intrinsically motivated toward those domains, or unless the programme structure
creates sufficient situational pressure to engage them. The Toastmasters programme creates that
situational pressure through the officer role structure — but only for members
who take up the roles. For members who
decline them, the pressure does not operate, and the transfer does not occur.
The members who develop interpersonal
skills are those who serve as officers, take mentoring seriously, and engage
the leadership track with the same rigour they apply to their speech
projects. The members who develop only
as speakers are using Toastmasters as a performance hobby. There is nothing wrong with that choice. It should not be confused with interpersonal
development.
The Verdict
The psychological evidence is consistent
with the observed reality in every club I have been associated with. Deliberate practice develops the specific
skill practised. Social learning theory
requires a social context with real stakes and real feedback. Leadership development requires stretch
assignments with genuine consequences.
Emotional intelligence requires repeated practice in conditions of
relational uncertainty. Speech delivery
provides none of the last three. Officer
roles, evaluation practice, and mentoring provide all of them.
Toastmasters develops interpersonal skills
for members who engage the leadership track.
It does not develop them for members who treat it as a speaking
club. The question of whether it will
develop your interpersonal skills has the same answer as the question of
whether the gymnasium will improve your fitness. It depends on what you do when you get there.
Terence
Nunis, DTM | Division Advisor, District 80 Division M | Club Advisor,
AIA Toastmasters | Past President & Founder, Awesome Toastmasters

No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.