23 February, 2020

Quora Answer: How Would the World Respond to a War between Australia & China?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “How would the world respond to a war between Australia and China?”

This is one of those stupid scenario questions that ignore reality.  The distance between Australia and China is over 7,000 kilometres.  This is not a minor operational inconvenience.  It is a structural impossibility for sustained conventional military conflict.

Military power projection across intercontinental distances requires strategic lift capability — the aircraft, the ships, the logistical infrastructure, and the pre-positioned supply chains to move combat-ready forces and sustain them far from home.  The United States is the only nation on earth that has invested in this capability at scale.  The US Military Sealift Command operates 125 ships.  The US Air Force operates 222 C-17 Globemaster III strategic airlifters.  The US has eleven aircraft carrier strike groups.  This infrastructure was built over seventy years at a cost of trillions of dollars to project and sustain military power anywhere on earth.  Even then, they are struggling.

Nobody else has it.  Not Russia, despite its nuclear arsenal.  Not China, despite its extraordinary conventional military expansion.  Certainly not Australia, whose entire defence budget of A$56 billion in 2026 —US$36 billion — represents 4 per cent of the US defence budget.

China’s People’s Liberation Army Navy has been expanding its blue-water capability at remarkable speed.  It operates two operational aircraft carriers with a third under construction.  But carrier capability and power projection capability are not the same thing.  A carrier provides air cover for a fleet.  It does not provide the amphibious shipping, the logistics vessels, the pre-positioned supply infrastructure, or the aerial refuelling capacity to land and sustain a combat force 7,000 kilometres from home against active resistance.

Australia’s situation is symmetrical.  The Australian Defence Force is a credible regional military with genuine capability in its own approaches.  It operates modern equipment, well-trained personnel, and the intelligence relationships that come with Five Eyes membership.  It is not structured, equipped, or funded to project sustained conventional combat power across 7,000 kilometres of ocean against the world’s largest standing army.

The two nations cannot fight each other in any meaningful conventional sense.  They are too far apart, and neither has the logistics.

China Holds All the Economic Cards

The economic relationship between Australia and China makes the war scenario not merely logistically implausible but economically catastrophic for Australia specifically.  China is Australia’s largest trading partner by a significant margin.  In the 2025 financial year, China accounted for 33 per cent of Australia’s total exports —A$230 billion.  Iron ore alone accounts for most of this figure.  Australia exported A$136 billion worth of iron ore to China in 2025.  The Pilbara region of Western Australia — whose iron ore feeds China’s steel industry — is the single most important source of the raw material that builds Chinese cities, Chinese infrastructure, and Chinese industrial capacity.

The relationship is not merely significant.  It is structural.  China’s steel industry cannot easily substitute Australian iron ore in the short to medium term.  Australia cannot easily redirect A$230 billion in annual exports to alternative markets.  The bilateral trade relationship is a mutual dependency — but the dependency is asymmetric.  Australia’s terms of trade — the ratio of export prices to import prices — have been historically elevated because Chinese demand for Australian commodities has kept export prices high.  The Reserve Bank of Australia’s monetary policy, the Commonwealth’s fiscal position, and the investment returns in Australian superannuation funds are all partially dependent on sustained Chinese demand for Australian resources.

A trade war — let alone a hot war — would collapse Australian commodity export prices, reduce government revenues, increase unemployment in the resources sector, and trigger a recession in the states most dependent on resources exports.  Western Australia, Queensland, and South Australia would bear the immediate brunt.  The federal budget — which depends heavily on company tax from resources exporters — would deteriorate sharply.  Australia’s political class understands this, whatever its public rhetoric suggests.

Rhetoric is Not Policy

Australian political discourse on China has oscillated between strategic competition anxiety and economic pragmatism for the better part of a decade.  The AUKUS agreement — announced in September 2021 — committed Australia to acquiring nuclear-powered submarines in cooperation with the United States and the United Kingdom.  The rhetoric surrounding AUKUS was framed in terms of countering Chinese military expansion in the Indo-Pacific.

China responded by imposing a series of trade restrictions on Australian exports — targeting barley, wine, coal, beef, cotton, and timber — between 2020 and 2021.  The restrictions were not framed as retaliation, but their timing, scope, and targeting were precise.  They hit Australian agricultural exporters, wine producers, and coal miners — sectors with political constituencies — while leaving iron ore untouched.  China needed the iron ore.  The message was delivered through the sectors it could afford to target.

The Australian response was to seek alternative markets, absorb the losses, and wait.  By 2023, China began lifting the trade restrictions progressively.  The iron ore relationship was never interrupted.  The political tensions eased.  Trade resumed.  The episode demonstrated the basic structure of the relationship: China can cause significant economic pain to specific Australian industries without touching the core resource dependency.  Australia can absorb that pain and complain diplomatically.  Neither side has the incentive to escalate beyond manageable economic pressure.

The AUKUS Reality Check

AUKUS has been presented in some quarters as evidence of Australian strategic commitment to military confrontation with China.  This misreads the instrument.  The nuclear-powered submarines that Australia is acquiring under AUKUS will not be operational until at least the late 2030s under the most optimistic schedules.  Australia will purchase the first submarines from the United States — specifically Virginia-class SSNs — with Australian-built submarines following under a collaborative programme.  The total cost has been estimated at between A$268 billion and A$368 billion over the life of the programme.

These submarines are strategic deterrent assets — the kind of platforms that operate in contested waters to deny adversaries freedom of manoeuvre, gather intelligence, and provide assured second-strike capability.  They are not the kind of assets you use to invade a country 7,000 kilometres away.  They are the kind of assets you use to make the cost of threatening Australia prohibitively high.  The distinction is between deterrence and aggression.  AUKUS is a deterrence investment.  It is expensive, slow, and strategically sound.  It is not evidence of Australian intent to initiate conflict with China.

The Hot War is Political Suicide

The Australian political system cannot survive the economic consequences of a hot war with China.  This is not a moral observation.  It is a structural one.  Any Australian prime minister who initiated or substantially contributed to the conditions for armed conflict with China would preside over a collapse in commodity export revenues, a sharp recession, a deterioration in the federal budget, and the displacement of workers in the country’s most economically significant sectors.  The political consequences would arrive before the military ones.  The government would fall.

The Opposition — whatever its party — would campaign on economic damage and win.  Australian politics has shown, repeatedly, that economic management concerns override foreign policy positioning when the two come into conflict.  The 2020 to 2021 trade restrictions did not produce an escalatory Australian response.  They produced diplomatic complaints and market diversification efforts.  The Australian government can be belligerent in rhetoric.  It can sign defence agreements, purchase submarines, and participate in allied exercises.  It cannot initiate or sustain a conflict that would collapse its own export economy.  The voter who loses their mining job is a more immediate political threat than the adversary 7,000 kilometres away.

What Actually Happens

The realistic scenario space between Australia and China contains exactly one form of conflict: trade friction.  Trade friction — the selective targeting of Australian exports through tariffs, quotas, biosecurity measures, and informal import restrictions — is the instrument China has already deployed and Australia has already survived.  It is painful.  It is manageable.  It resolves through negotiation, market diversification, and the gradual recognition that mutual economic interests outweigh bilateral political grievances.

The most acute version of this scenario involves Chinese restrictions on iron ore — the one lever that has not yet been pulled.  If China were to restrict Australian iron ore imports, the economic consequences for Australia would be severe, and the consequences for China’s steel industry would be significant but manageable through Brazilian and African supply diversification over a multi-year period.  The scenario is theoretically possible and practically unlikely because it hurts both sides more than the alternatives.

Beyond trade friction, the scenario space involves Australian participation in allied operations in the South China Sea or Taiwan Strait — not as a lead actor but as a contributor to US-led coalition operations.  This is the realistic military scenario: Australian submarines operating in contested waters, Australian surface vessels participating in freedom of navigation operations, Australian intelligence assets contributing to allied situational awareness.  This is strategic competition, not war.

The Summary

The war between Australia and China does not happen because the logistics make it impossible, the economics make it suicidal, and the political system makes it unsustainable for any government that initiates it.  Australia and China will continue to have a complicated relationship — trade dependency combined with strategic competition; economic interdependence combined with divergent values and interests.  This is the relationship between most significant trading partners in the contemporary world.  It is managed through diplomacy, sustained through commerce, and occasionally disrupted by political rhetoric that neither side intends to act upon.

The most we will see is a trade war.  We have already had one.  We survived it.  The iron ore kept flowing throughout.  The world would respond to an Australia-China war with bewilderment — because the war would be over before the world had finished formulating its response, and it would be over because both sides ran out of logistics before either ran out of will.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.