The
following is my answer to a Quora question: “How
does inflation in a fiat currency system compare to deflation in a gold
standard system, and why is one considered more manageable?”
This
is a bullshit question. The question
frames inflation under a fiat currency system and deflation under a gold
standard as two comparable policy choices, between which economists and
policymakers must select the more manageable option. This framing is wrong. It assumes the gold standard is a viable
alternative to fiat currency in a modern economy — an assumption that the
historical record does not support and that serious monetary economists have
long since abandoned. The comparison is
not between two equally plausible monetary frameworks. It is between a system that exists and
functions, however imperfectly, and a system that was tried, failed, and was
abandoned for documented reasons.
What
are Inflation and Deflation?
Inflation
is the sustained increase in the general price level — the purchasing power of
money declining over time. Under a fiat
currency system, the central bank controls the money supply and sets interest
rates to manage inflation within a target range. The US Federal Reserve, the European Central
Bank, and the Monetary Authority of Singapore all target 2 per cent annual
inflation — a figure chosen because modest inflation is compatible with
economic growth, full employment, and manageable debt dynamics.
Deflation
is the sustained decrease in the general price level — the purchasing power of
money increasing over time. This sounds
benign. It is not. Deflation produces a well-documented economic
pathology: when prices are falling, consumers defer purchases because the same
money will buy more tomorrow than today.
Businesses facing falling prices reduce investment and employment. Wages fall.
Debt burdens increase in real terms because the nominal debt obligation
remains fixed while the value of money rises.
The economy contracts.
Japan’s
experience between 1991 and 2013 — two decades of near-zero inflation and
periodic deflation following the collapse of its asset price bubble — is the
most extensively studied modern case.
Real GDP growth averaged 0.8 per cent annually during this period. The Nikkei 225, which peaked at 38,957 in
December 1989, did not recover to that level for 34 years. The Bank of Japan cut interest rates to zero
and eventually introduced quantitative easing because deflation was so damaging
and so difficult to escape once entrenched.
Japan did not operate under a gold standard. The point is that deflation, even in a modern
managed economy with full central bank toolkit availability, produced decades
of stagnation. The gold standard would
have provided none of the tools that allowed Japan to eventually exit
deflation.
The
Gold Standard’s Historical Record
The
gold standard was not abandoned because economists or politicians disliked it
philosophically. It was abandoned
because it failed — repeatedly and catastrophically — to manage economic
crises. The classical gold standard —
under which major economies fixed their currencies to gold at defined parities
— operated from 1870 to 1914. It
produced a period of relative monetary stability in developed economies. It also produced periodic banking panics —
1873, 1884, 1890, 1893, 1896, 1907 — because the money supply could not expand
to meet liquidity crises. The Federal
Reserve was established in 1913 partly in response to the 1907 panic, because a
system without a lender of last resort was inadequate.
The
gold standard’s most catastrophic failure was the Great Depression. Between 1929 and 1933, US GDP fell 30 per
cent. Unemployment reached 25 per
cent. The money supply contracted by one-third
because the Federal Reserve, constrained by gold reserve requirements, could
not expand the money supply to meet the liquidity crisis. Banks failed.
Credit contracted. Prices
fell. The debt deflation spiral that
Professor Irving Fisher of Yale University described in his 1933 paper, The
Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions, consumed the economy with no
mechanism for escape. The countries that
abandoned the gold standard earliest recovered fastest. The United Kingdom left the gold standard in
September 1931. Its economy began
recovering almost immediately thereafter.
The United States left the gold standard domestically in 1933 —
President Franklin Delano Roosevelt suspended gold convertibility and devalued
the dollar — and the economy began recovering.
The countries that clung to gold — France, Germany, Belgium, the
Netherlands — suffered longer and deeper depressions.
Professor
Barry Julian Eichengreen of the University of California, Berkeley — whose
research on the gold standard and the Great Depression is the most
authoritative in the field — documented this relationship comprehensively in Golden
Fetters: The Gold Standard and the Great Depression, 1919-1939 (1992). The title is not subtle. The gold standard was a constraint that
prevented the monetary policy response that recovery required.
Why
the Comparison is False
The
question compares inflation in a fiat system with deflation in a gold standard
system as if both are policy-adjustable variables. They are not symmetrically adjustable. Under a fiat currency system, inflation is
manageable because the central bank has tools to address it. Interest rate increases reduce the money
supply, cool demand, and bring inflation down.
The Federal Reserve raised the Federal Funds Rate from near zero to 5.25
per cent between March 2022 and July 2023, bringing US inflation from 9.1 per
cent — a 40-year high — down to approximately 3 per cent by mid-2023. The tool worked. It was painful. It was deliberate. It worked.
Under
a gold standard, deflation is not manageable in the same way because the tools
do not exist. The money supply is
constrained by gold reserves. Interest
rates cannot be reduced below the rate required to maintain the gold peg
without triggering capital outflows and gold reserve depletion. The central bank cannot expand the money
supply to break the deflationary spiral.
The economy must deflate until prices have fallen far enough that
competitiveness is restored — a process that, as the 1930s demonstrated, takes
years and produces enormous human suffering.
The fiat currency system permits policy error and policy
correction. The gold standard permitted
policy error and offered no correction mechanism beyond austerity and waiting.
The
Argument for Gold
The
gold standard’s contemporary advocates make a legitimate point: fiat currency
systems permit governments to inflate away their debts, debase their
currencies, and transfer wealth from savers to debtors through monetary
expansion. This criticism is
accurate. The purchasing power of the US
dollar has declined by 97 per cent since the Federal Reserve was established in
1913. A dollar in 1913 bought what US$30
buys today. This is a real cost. It is also a cost that the holders of fiat
money have accepted in exchange for living in economies that survived the Great
Depression, the Second World War, the 2008 financial crisis, and the COVID-19
pandemic without the catastrophic monetary contractions that the gold standard
would have produced.
The
choice between fiat currency inflation and gold standard deflation is not a
choice between two equivalent monetary systems.
It is a choice between a system with manageable flaws and a system with
unmanageable ones. The fiat system’s
flaws — inflation, currency debasement, government overspending — are real,
documented, and addressable through policy.
The gold standard’s flaws — deflation, procyclical money supply
contraction, inability to respond to liquidity crises — are equally real,
equally documented, and not addressable through policy because the gold
standard eliminates the policy tools required to address them.
The
Great Depression settled this debate empirically. The academic literature settled it
theoretically. The question of which is
more manageable has a clear answer: the system whose problems can be managed is
more manageable than the system whose problems cannot. Inflation at 9 per cent, as the United States
experienced in 2022, is painful. It was
brought down to target within eighteen months.
The Great Depression’s deflation took a decade and a world war to
resolve. The comparison is not between
equals. It never was.
Terence
Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The
Billionaire Cheat Code

No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.