Quora Answer: What Effect Did Japan’s Switch from the Silver Standard to the Gold Standard Have on the Yen’s Value against Other Currencies?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “What effect did Japan’s switch from the silver standard to the gold standard have on the yen’s value against other currencies?”

We need to look at history to understand the parallel.  Japan switched from silver to gold on 1^st October 1897.  The move ended three decades of yen instability against Britain, America, and every other major trading partner already on gold.

Silver fell roughly 20 per cent against gold between 1873 and the end of that decade alone, then kept sliding through the 1880s and into the 1890s as country after country abandoned it: Germany in 1873, most of Europe by the late 1870s, Hungary in 1892, Russia in 1897.  The yen, tied to silver throughout this period, depreciated against the pound, the dollar, and every other gold-standard currency in step with that decline.  A Japanese importer paying for British machinery, or the Japanese government borrowing from London, paid steadily more yen for the same gold-priced good or loan, year after year, for over two decades.

China’s 1895 defeat in the First Sino-Japanese War funded the fix.  The Treaty of Shimonoseki forced China to pay Japan 230 million silver kuping taels, roughly £38 million, or ¥356 million.  Japan used that indemnity to build the gold reserve backing its new standard.  The gold yen was fixed at half the weight of the US gold dollar, worth roughly 50 US cents, nearly identical to the silver yen’s market value of 51 cents at the moment of transition.  The switch cost nothing in relative value at the point of conversion.  It existed to stop future losses.

It worked immediately.  The rate held close to two yen per dollar for the following three decades, until Japan left gold again in 1931.  Exchange-rate risk against Japan’s major trading partners, Britain, the United States, and the rest of gold-standard Europe, effectively disappeared overnight.  Finance officials such as Korekiyo Takahashi pushed the move specifically to remove that risk, expecting lower borrowing costs and stronger foreign investment as a direct result.  Baron Eiichi Shibusawa, the leading industrialist of the era, opposed the switch, arguing exporters had profited for a decade from the weak silver yen.  The reformers won the argument, and the following three decades of currency stability proved them right.

The Regional Story Matters More Than the Global One

China stayed on silver.  It remained the last major economy still using it, all the way through the First World War and into the 1930s.  That single fact split Japan and its largest regional neighbour onto two different currency paths from 1897 onward.  The yen stabilised against gold.  China’s silver-based currency kept depreciating alongside global silver for decades longer.  Japanese exporters and lenders dealing with the gold-standard world gained a stability advantage over Chinese counterparts operating in the same regional trade network, a structural edge Japan converted into cheaper foreign borrowing and stronger foreign investment inflows in the years that followed.

Slower Movement Costs More Now Than It Did in 1897

Japan’s population has been shrinking for over a decade, with births falling to record lows and the workforce contracting every year that follows.  A demographic collapse this severe needs monetary and fiscal policy willing to move as decisively as the 1897 government moved, not a central bank still debating quarter-point increments while a currency crisis forces a joint intervention with Washington.  Japan proved in 1897 it could fix a currency problem in a single legislative session when the political will existed.  It has spent the past three decades proving the opposite: that caution, extended long enough, becomes its own kind of failure, one a shrinking population has considerably less time to recover from than a nineteenth-century economy still building its industrial base.

---

Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code