01 February, 2020

Quora Answer: Do Trusts Lead to Wealth Concentrating over Time?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “Does the use of trusts to protect assets lead to concentrating wealth, in the hands of the few, over time?”

That really depends.  A trust is a container.  The drafter decides whether it disperses wealth or hoards it.  Singapore law sets the limits on the container.  History explains why those limits exist.  The trust began as a dodge.  Medieval churchmen invented the “use” to escape the Statutes of Mortmain.  Edward I, King of England, passed them in 1279 and again in 1290 to stop land passing to the Church.  A friend held the land.  The Church enjoyed the profit.  The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica adds that uses also served to defeat creditors.

Kings noticed the leak.  Henry VIII, King of England, passed the Statute of Uses in 1535 to restore the feudal dues that uses evaded.  Lawyers answered with the “use upon a use”.  The modern trust grew from that workaround.  Creditors fought back through the courts.  Twyne’s Case, decided in 1601, is the classic.  A farmer sold his sheep to a man named Twyne and kept shearing them.  The court voided the sale.  The Fraudulent Conveyances Act 1571 stood behind it.  Singapore’s section 73B of the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act 1886 is its descendant.

The Dead Hand

Landed families then built long trusts.  They tied estates to bloodlines with entails and settlements.  The courts pushed back.  Lord Chancellor Nottingham, Heneage Finch, decided the Duke of Norfolk’s Case in 1682.  It produced the rule against perpetuities.  Property cannot stay locked up forever.

The great estates lasted anyway.  Sir Thomas Grosvenor married Mary Davies in 1677.  She was 12.  She brought marshland west of London.  Today it is Mayfair and Belgravia.  Hugh Richard Louis Grosvenor, the 7th Duke of Westminster, inherited the estate in 2016.  Bloomberg values its controlled assets at £9.5 billion on 31st December 2025.  The family holds it through trusts, and the 7th Duke is a beneficiary and chair of trustees, not the legal owner.  Chambers Student reports that the structure avoided a multibillion-pound tax bill.

Regression to the mean is real when heirs split an estate equally.  It is fiction when the settlement says one line inherits.  A 12-year-old brought the marshland.  Her descendants have collected the rent for 349 years.

The Monopoly Trust

Then the trust became a weapon.  Samuel Calvin Tate Dodd, attorney to John Davison Rockefeller, adapted the trust to Standard Oil.  On 2nd January 1882, 41 investors pooled securities of 40 companies under nine trustees.  Rockefeller held 41 per cent of the trust certificates.  The public came to associate “trust” with monopoly.

Congress answered with the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890.  The Senate voted 51 to 1 and the House 242 to nothing.  The Supreme Court ordered Standard Oil broken into 34 companies on 15th May 1911.  Exxon and Chevron descend from the pieces.  Many of them recombined.

The Dynasty Trust

The American tax code produced the modern version.  Congress enacted the generation-skipping transfer tax in 1986 to close a loophole.  States answered by abolishing the perpetuities rule.  South Dakota went first in 1983.  Delaware followed in 1995, and the du Pont family’s influence over that state is a well-known part of the story.  24/7 Wall St reports that US$900 billion of family money now sits in South Dakota trusts.  That figure is a reported estimate.

Singapore Receives the Law

Singapore inherited English equity.  I take the route from the Second Charter of Justice of 1826 to the Application of English Law Act 1993 from my own knowledge.  The Trustees Act 1967 grew from the English Trustee Act 1925 and the Trustees Ordinance.  The Trust Companies Act 2005 licenses professional trustees under the Monetary Authority of Singapore.  It came into force on 1st February 2006.  Practitioner guides say the Hague Trusts Convention does not apply in Singapore.

In the Singapore context, four rules matter.

Duration.  The Civil Law Act 1909 fixes a perpetuity period of 100 years for private trusts taking effect on or after 15th December 2004.  A longer period in a deed is deemed to be 100 years.  Practitioners complain that other jurisdictions have abolished the cap.  I would keep it.  It is the only statutory brake on duration.  The wealth data below argues for caution.

Control.  The Trustees Act lets a settlor reserve powers without invalidating the trust.  A settlor can keep investment control and still call the assets the trust’s.

Privacy.  Practitioner guides report that Singapore keeps no public register of private trusts.  The Ministry of Finance itself warns that top-end wealth data suffers from under-reporting.  Opacity helps concentration hide.

Creditors.  Section 73B makes any conveyance made with intent to defraud creditors voidable.  The Trustees Act repeats the rule for trusts.  Part of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (IRDA) reaches transactions at an undervalue.  The Court of Appeal applied section 73B in Ng Bok Eng Holdings Pte. Ltd. v Wong Ser Wan in 2005.  In 2024, the High Court in Envy Asset Management Pte Ltd (in liquidation) v CH Biovest Pte. Ltd. set aside fictitious Ponzi profits under the same section.  A trust shields assets from honest creditors.  It does not shield them from fraud.

Singapore uses taxes as brakes.  Stamp duty is one.  Since 27 April 2023, Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty is 65 per cent on residential property bought by trustees.  Trusts for identifiable beneficiaries can claim partial or full refunds.  Property tax is the other.

Estate duty was the third.  Singapore levied it from 1929 until 15th February 2008.  Tharman Shanmugaratnam, then Finance Minister, abolished it.  He said estate duty prevents wealth “from being concentrated in fewer and fewer hands over time”, and that it mattered most when wealth was land passed down through families.  He argued that attracting wealth to Singapore would benefit the whole economy.  He kept property tax because it is harder to avoid.

The Data

The Ministry of Finance published Singapore’s first official wealth data in February 2026.  The top 1 per cent of households hold 14 per cent of wealth.  The top 5 per cent hold 33 per cent.  The wealth Gini is 0.55.  The income Gini after taxes and transfers is 0.379, the lowest in a decade.  Redistribution works on income.  It does not reach wealth.

UBS puts Singapore’s average wealth per adult at US$527,217, sixth in the world.  Median wealth is US$96,434, twentieth.  The country has 244,000 US-dollar millionaires and 55 billionaires with a combined US$258.8 billion, up 66.4 per cent from 2024.  The Economic Development Board reports single-family offices rose tenfold in five years to more than 2,000 by the end of 2024.

In Summary

Trusts do not concentrate wealth by themselves.  Design does.  Equal division among many heirs dilutes.  Discretionary control, restricted inheritance, and long duration concentrate.  Singapore bounds duration at 100 years, polices fraud under section 73B, and taxes property purchases heavily.  It has no estate duty and no trust register.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.