22 September, 2020

Quora Answer: Will Malaysia Fight China if China Forcefully Tries to Claim Singapore as Part of Its Territory?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “Will Malaysia fight China if China forcefully tries to claim Singapore as part of its territory?”

What an utterly ridiculous question.  China has no historical claim over Singapore.  Singapore is a sovereign state, almost 4,000 kilometres away.  It is nowhere near China.

If the assumption is that China could invade Singapore, that remains impossible.  Even discounting Singapore’s own military entirely, China lacks the lift capacity to send a significant force that far.  The Pentagon’s own 2025 Annual Report to Congress confirms this.  A Reuters investigation, tracking vessel movements and satellite imagery through 2025, found China rehearsing amphibious landings using civilian roll-on, roll-off ferries and cargo ships, because the PLA Navy’s own purpose-built amphibious fleet cannot generate sufficient first-wave capacity on its own.  Military analysts estimate China can land roughly 20,000 troops in a first wave, against a task requiring 300,000 to 1 million troops or more to subdue a defended target the size of Taiwan.  Activating civilian shipping for this purpose gives weeks, if not months, of advance warning, since these vessels cannot simply vanish from commercial tracking data.

If China possessed this capability, it would have used it against Taiwan first.  Taiwan sits 130 kilometres away at the strait’s narrowest point.  China has spent decades building toward that objective and, by the Pentagon’s own current assessment, still has not closed the gap.  Singapore is thirty times further away, across contested Southeast Asian waters, requiring sustained resupply and air cover the PLA cannot yet guarantee even for the closer Taiwan scenario.

Singapore’s Own Position

Singapore remains the most militarised state in Southeast Asia, ranked 29th globally by GlobalMilitary.net’s 2026 assessment, fielding the region’s most modern air force and navy.  Singapore’s 2005 Strategic Framework Agreement with the United States, reinforced by the 2015 Enhanced Defence Cooperation Agreement, gives the US Navy standing access to Changi Naval Base, one of the few facilities in the world built to accommodate a full US aircraft carrier.  The US Navy’s Logistics Group Western Pacific operates from Singapore, coordinating warship deployment and logistics across the region, and Littoral Combat Ships and P-8 Poseidon aircraft run continuous rotational patrols from Singaporean waters.  The Horsburgh Lighthouse approach into the Singapore Strait remains a natural chokepoint, and any flotilla approaching from the south through the Karimata Strait would be picked up by radar coverage from Singapore’s southern islands long before reaching striking distance, facing an immediate air cover disadvantage in those waters.

Malaysia Remains a Non-Factor

Malaysia’s Armed Forces continue suffering from the arms procurement dysfunction the original answer identified in 2020.  In July 2026, Norway cancelled a US$145 million Naval Strike Missile contract with Malaysia, originally signed in 2018 for the Royal Malaysian Navy’s Maharaja Lela-class littoral combat ships, after more than 95 per cent of the contract value had already been paid.  The missile cancellation followed from delays plaguing Malaysia’s own Littoral Combat Ship programme, contracted to Boustead Naval Shipyard in 2014 for six vessels originally due by 2018.  Not one had been delivered years past that deadline.  Malaysia criticised Norway’s decision, though the delay and cost overrun sat on Malaysia’s own side of the contract.  A navy that cannot take delivery of its own littoral combat ships after twelve years, and loses a paid-for missile contract as a direct consequence, has no means to project itself in any serious naval or air engagement.  It will take more than a procurement reshuffle to rebuild the Malaysian Armed Forces into a credible deterrent, and nothing in the record since 2020 suggests that rebuild has begun.

Let alone coming to the aid of Singapore, a regional military power, Malaysia is not even in a credible position to defend its own sovereignty from lesser threats.  If there were a conflict of any sort, perhaps having Malaysia on the same side would be a hindrance more than a help.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code


No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.