01 February, 2020

Quora Answer: Do You Lose Money in a Savings Account?

The following is my answer to a Quora question: “Do you lose money in a savings account?”

The savings account is one of the great confidence tricks of the retail banking industry.  The bank takes your money, lends it at four to eight per cent to someone buying a car or a flat, and pays you a fraction of that in return.  You call this saving.  The bank calls it inventory management.

Singapore’s headline inflation was 1.6 per cent in December 2024.  The Monetary Authority of Singapore projected core inflation to average between 1.0 and 2.0 per cent in 2025.  That is the official figure — the Consumer Price Index basket, which measures a selection of goods and services chosen by statisticians.  The CPI does not fully capture the real experience of inflation: the plate of prawn noodles that costs more and arrives with fewer prawns, the taxi fare that rises while the ride gets shorter due to peak-hour charges, the flat that costs twice what it cost a decade ago while the mortgage tenure stretches to thirty-five years.  Lived inflation consistently outpaces reported inflation for the simple reason that the basket is curated, not comprehensive.

Apply a working assumption of 2.5 per cent annual inflation — the figure that the CPF Ordinary Account uses as its floor rate — and measure every return against it. The standard DBS, OCBC, and UOB savings accounts pay between 0.05 and 0.10 per cent per annum on base balances.  The highest published savings account rate in Singapore as of May 2025 was the Citibank Wealth First Account at 7.51 per cent — achievable only if you simultaneously credit your salary, spend $250 per month on a Citibank debit card, invest $50,000 in a lump sum, purchase $50,000 in single-premium insurance, and take a $500,000 home loan.  The OCBC 360 Account, after its May 2025 rate cut from 7.65 per cent, now offers up to 6.30 per cent on the first $100,000, subject to similar conditions.  The UOB One Account, simpler but less rewarding, caps at 3.30 per cent effective per annum on the first $150,000.

Strip out the conditions, and the ordinary saver earns between 0.05 and 0.10 per cent.  Against 2.5 per cent inflation, the loss in real terms is 2.4 per cent annually.  On $100,000, that is $2,400 per year, every year, disappearing while the balance on the screen stays nominally unchanged.  The bank does not send you a bill.  It simply ensures you are poorer in purchasing power each December than you were in January.  The wealthy do not use savings accounts for wealth accumulation.  They use savings accounts for liquidity — short-term cash management, immediate access to operating funds, nothing more.  This is not a secret.  It is simply never explained to the people for whom the savings account was designed.

Here are three alternatives worth considering.

Singapore Savings Bonds

The November 2026 Singapore Savings Bond (SBNOV26) offers a 10-year average return of 2.45 per cent per annum, with a first-year rate of 1.67 per cent rising to 3.08 per cent in year 10.  The bond is government-guaranteed, fully liquid with no penalty for early redemption, and available in amounts as low as $500.  The 10-year average is marginally below the CPF Ordinary Account floor of 2.5 per cent, but it exceeds the base savings account rate by a factor of twenty-five.  For cash you will not need immediately, this is an unremarkable but reliable instrument.

Singapore REITs

Listed Real Estate Investment Trusts on the Singapore Exchange offer higher yields.  As of October 2025, Mapletree Industrial Trust traded at a yield of 5.9 per cent, Mapletree Logistics Trust at 5.6 per cent, and Mapletree Pan Asia Commercial Trust at 5.5 per cent.  These are not guaranteed returns — distributions depend on rental income, occupancy rates, and interest cost management — but they represent income-generating assets backed by physical property, managed by listed entities subject to MAS oversight and SGX disclosure requirements.  A 5.5 to 5.9 per cent yield against 2.5 per cent inflation leaves a real return of 3.0 to 3.4 per cent, compared to a negative 2.4 per cent in a standard savings account.  That is a 5.8 percentage point differential.  Compounded over a decade, it is the difference between financial stagnation and meaningful wealth accumulation.

Whole-of-Life Insurance with Participating Funds

A whole-of-life policy with a participating fund component does something no savings account can: it guarantees a sum assured regardless of market conditions, accumulates a cash value that grows at the insurer’s declared bonus rate, and simultaneously provides life coverage that removes the need for a separate term policy.  Participating fund declared bonuses in Singapore have historically run between 3.0 and 5.5 per cent on the investment component, though past rates do not guarantee future ones.  More critically, the policy creates a structured, illiquid reserve that removes the temptation to spend — a feature that most people, if they are candid, need more than they need flexibility.  The coverage also transfers wealth outside the estate on death, bypassing the delays of probate that can freeze a savings account balance for twelve to thirty-six months while lawyers argue over paperwork.

The Broader Point

There is a reason ordinary people have savings accounts and wealthy people have portfolios, investment accounts, and structured insurance arrangements.  It is not because wealthy people are more financially sophisticated by nature.  It is because nobody selling a savings account has any incentive to explain its limitations.  The savings account is a product designed for the bank’s benefit, packaged as a service to yours.  It keeps your money accessible, earns the bank a spread, and gives you the comfortable illusion of financial prudence while inflation quietly reduces what that money can buy.  Saving is not the same as investing.  Knowing the difference is where financial literacy begins.  Acting on the difference is where wealth accumulation starts.


Terence Nunis | Executive Chairman, Equinox Zenith | Author, The 1% Playbook: The Billionaire Cheat Code



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.