14 September, 2019

Tall Tales at Toa Payoh Central Toastmasters: When Lying Well is a Competitive Sport

On 10th September 2019, I was at Toa Payoh Central Toastmasters Club.  This was my 54th club visit of the Toastmasters year, on day seventy-four.  I was there as a Contest Judge.  The Contest Toastmaster of the Day was Alpha Khu.  The contest chair was Mikhail Kho.  The chief judge was Gerald Ong, DTM.  There were seven contestants.

What the Contest Judges

The Tall Tales rubric scores delivery at 55 per cent, content at 30 per cent, and language at 15 per cent.  A mediocre story told brilliantly beats a funny story told badly.  Most contestants learn this after the results.

The Speakers

Roger Sng defended Singapore from a tiger at Pulau Tekong, thirty years prior.  Amusing in parts.  The premise had legs.  The execution did not use them.

A. Rajah Vadivel took his wife to the mysterious city of “Eropagnis” – Singapore, reversed.  Half the room had decoded it before he reached the punchline.  When the reveal lands before the punch, the punch lands soft.

Muhammad Mohsin held a Pakistani passport and wanted to attend his brother’s wedding in the United States.  By the time the American embassy, the TSA, and the full machinery of bureaucratic paranoia had finished with him, the wedding was two years past.  He attended his nephew’s first birthday instead.  It was not strictly a tall tale — it was an actual account.  The American immigration system requires no embellishment to be funny.  Reality did the work.  The judges noted the absence of invention.

Tan Ping Hong announced he had been cast in a new Mr Kiasu production.  Mr Kiasu — the Singaporean everyman pathologically terrified of losing out — has been a pop culture fixture since the early 1990s.  Whether this was the tall tale or the truth, only Tan knows.

Paulus Gunadi was an expert snake catcher with a pet snake.  Nervous about asking a woman out, he rehearsed by talking to the snake, pretending it was her.  The snake bit him.  Then it died.  Clean structure.  Patient build.  The punchline landed as a double blow — the man survived; the snake did not.  The audience drew its own conclusions about his conversational abilities.  First runner-up.

Ershvinder Kaur played the innocent.  An innocent who had, apparently, stumbled into the orbit of loan shark runners, Nigerian advance-fee fraudsters, and assorted confidence artists.  She described these misadventures with the air of someone recounting a dull commute.  Deadpan is the hardest technique in the Tall Tales arsenal — the moment the speaker acknowledges the joke, the joke dies.  Ershvinder never acknowledged it.  The room split.  She won.

Ong Keh Yoe claimed superpowers and pivoted to a lecture on plastics.  The misdirection structure was there.  The execution ran out of steam before the speech did.

The Verdict

Winner: Ershvinder Kaur.  First runner-up: Paulus J. Gunadi.  Second runner-up: A. Rajah Vadivel.

Craft beat concept.  The audience never got ahead of Ershvinder.  That is the difference between a winner and a contestant.

At least three speakers have the foundation for Division level.  Foundation and result are separated by one thing: refinement, not repetition.


Terence Nunis, DTM | Division Advisor, District 80 Division M | Club Advisor, AIA Toastmasters | Past President & Founder, Awesome Toastmasters











No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be poster.